H.R. 9278

H.R. 9278: To amend title 5, United States Code, to provide that judicial review under the Administrative Procedure Act requires de novo trial of the facts when agency action seeks a sanction.

Introduced Harriet Hageman (R) HOUSE_BILL — 119th Congress
Plain English Summary

H.R. 9278 proposes to change the way courts review certain actions taken by federal agencies. Specifically, it aims to ensure that when an agency imposes a sanction, the court must conduct a new trial that examines the facts of the case from scratch, rather than simply reviewing the agency's decision.

Positive Media Summary

Supporters of H.R. 9278 argue that it enhances fairness in the judicial process by allowing for a thorough examination of the facts in cases involving agency sanctions. They believe this will lead to more just outcomes for individuals and entities affected by government actions.

Negative Media Summary

Critics of H.R. 9278 claim that requiring a de novo trial for agency sanctions could overwhelm the judicial system and lead to increased litigation costs. They argue that this could hinder the ability of agencies to enforce regulations effectively and slow down the administrative process.

TheBillRoom is free and independent. No ads, no subscriptions, no political funding. If this analysis was useful, reader support keeps it running.
Support Us